Managing in Bull and Bear Markets
B-School Search
For the latest academic year, we have over 250 schools in our BSchools.org database and those that advertise with us are labeled “sponsor”. When you click on a sponsoring school or program, or fill out a form to request information from a sponsoring school, we may earn a commission. View our advertising disclosure for more details.
“The best leaders use favorable markets to build resilience. Technological, economic, and geopolitical shifts can arrive quickly. Adaptability is not merely a defensive strategy. It is a competitive advantage.”
Philip Russel, PhD, MBA, Professor of Finance and Dean of the College of Business at Thomas Jefferson University
Today’s MBA candidates are preparing for an uncertain future. Markets are exuberant: indices are at or near all-time highs, and AI investment is everywhere. But there’s also talk of a bubble: will AI live up to its promises, or drag down the labor market with it? The sentiment can shift from day to day and moment to moment. Good managers need to lead through all different kinds of market conditions.
Uncertainty is par for the course in business: ask someone who got their MBA during the Dot Com Bubble, or in the months when Covid first hit. But the skills taught in modern MBA programs are the building blocks for an entire career, even as that career may oscillate through multiple bull and bear markets.
To learn more about managing in bull and bear markets, and how MBA grads can prepare themselves to lead in an uncertain future, read on.
Meet the Expert: Philip Russel, PhD, MBA, MA
Dr. Philip Russel is a professor of finance and dean of the College of Business at Thomas Jefferson University. He earned his MBA from Morgan State University and his PhD in finance from the University of Massachusetts-Amherst.
At Jefferson, Dr. Russel has served as associate vice provost, dean of graduate studies, associate dean of Kanbar College, and program director of the undergraduate business program. He has also worked as an academic consultant for leading publishers and conducted workshops for the World Bank, the Certified Financial Planner (CFP) program, and the Canadian Securities Course.
Dr. Russel’s research focuses on corporate bankruptcy and managed portfolios. His work has been widely cited by media outlets such as CNBC, NPR, The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, and USA Today.
Meet the Expert: Mengxin Zhao, PhD, CFA
Dr. Mengxin Zhao is an associate professor of finance in the Costello College of Business at George Mason University. She earned her PhD in finance from the University of Pittsburgh and holds degrees in economics from SUNY Albany and Peking University.
Prior to joining the faculty at George Mason, Dr. Zhao served as a senior financial economist at the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and an associate professor at the University of Alberta. She has also taught at George Washington University, Boston University, and Bentley University.
Dr. Zhao’s research focuses on corporate finance, international finance, and capital market frictions. Her award-winning work has been published in the Journal of Finance, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Management Science, and Review of Corporate Finance Studies.
Managing in Today’s Market
“The current market presents an interesting mix of opportunities and risks,” Dr. Zhao says. “On the one hand, the economy has been fairly resilient, corporate earnings have been strong, and enthusiasm around AI is driving substantial investment. On the other hand, there are concerns about inflation and interest rates, as well as questions about whether the returns on some of these AI investments will justify the enormous spending.”
It’s an edgy time. War in Europe and the Middle East means heightened geopolitical risk; global supply chains can be disrupted overnight. Meanwhile, the labor market has its own jitters: according to the September 2026 job report, employers added only 29,000 jobs, largely concentrated in healthcare and construction, while jobs in financial services went down by 7,000, and job numbers from July and August were revised downward (BLS 2026).
There’s also the possibility that the AI boom, which is driving much of financial markets’ exuberance, might have aspects of a broader bust built into it. Both the white collar workforce (Citrini 2026) and cybersecurity standards are potentially under threat (Guardian 2026). While some elements of those risks may be overblown (Economist 2026), even AI companies themselves are ringing the alarm: Anthropic’s blockbuster IPO filing warns that AI could pose catastrophic or existential risks to humanity (BBC 2026).
“Businesses are navigating considerable uncertainty,” Dr. Russel says. “This environment asks leaders to pair optimism about emerging opportunities with a clear-eyed view of risk, and to be comfortable making decisions with incomplete information.”
Despite the risks, managers must not lose sight of where things are right now: markets are at or near their all-time highs. Investors are still optimistic, and it’s easier for companies to raise capital and invest aggressively, even when long-term returns are uncertain. That makes for a more forgiving environment in which managers and companies can try new approaches; even if those new approaches don’t work right away, they can lay the groundwork for innovation and growth.
Dr. Russel cites a case where McDonald’s tested AI voice ordering with IBM at roughly 100 drive-thrus. The pilot program lasted two and a half years before ending in 2024, amid customer complaints about misunderstood orders. Still, McDonald’s has said voice ordering remains part of its future, and has kept evaluating its options.
“The lesson is to pilot boldly, pairing technology with human judgment and ethical leadership,” Dr. Russel says. “Organizations that never test bold ideas risk being left behind.”
Taking Advantage of Favorable Conditions
“I think the key is to take advantage of favorable conditions without assuming they will last forever,” Dr. Zhao says. “When capital is readily available, companies should invest in profitable projects, develop their capabilities, and strengthen their competitive position. But they should avoid taking on too much debt or making commitments that only work if growth continues at a very high rate. Ultimately, what matters is not just how the market values a company today, but whether the company can create real economic value over time.”
Bull markets give managers the latitude to experiment and grow, but they’re also an opportunity to strengthen the business’s foundation. Markets are cyclical. No prevailing climate lasts forever. A business built to function only in favorable conditions will fail when conditions change.
“Peloton illustrates this risk,” Dr. Russel says. “Pandemic demand surged so quickly that the company expanded capacity, and when gyms reopened and demand fell, it was left with excess inventory and heavy losses. It later cut roughly 2,800 jobs, replaced its CEO, and canceled plans for a new US factory. A favorable market had been mistaken for a lasting shift.”
Favorable market conditions give businesses an opportunity to strengthen their balance sheets with all-weather investments. Beyond bolstering financial fundamentals, managers should invest in the talent, technology, operational capabilities, and customer relationships that make a business resilient and sustainable.
“One question I would think managers should ask is: Would this decision still make sense if the market became less favorable?” Dr. Zhao says. “If the answer is yes, they are probably building a more sustainable business.”
Managers should also look for ways to increase flexibility to respond when market sentiment changes. Dr. Russel advises scenario planning in advance: what if demand declines sharply or cost rises suddenly, competition intensifies, or a major disruption occurs? Working through these questions before they become crises means managers don’t have to predict when things change; instead, they can focus on building an organization capable of adapting when they do.
“The best leaders use favorable markets to build resilience,” Dr. Russel says. “Technological, economic, and geopolitical shifts can arrive quickly. Adaptability is not merely a defensive strategy. It is a competitive advantage.”
Preparing for a Bear Market
When markets turn, access to capital becomes more difficult, customers may spend less, and managers face much harder choices.
“The core principles of leading an organization do not change when markets turn, but the priorities do,” Dr. Russel says. “In my view, effective management has always rested on integrity, care for people, and a long-term view. In a strong market, managers focus on growth, innovation, and calculated risk-taking. When conditions deteriorate, they must become more disciplined about cash flow, costs, resource allocation, and risk management. The strongest leaders do not wait for a downturn to build that discipline. They cultivate it in advance and know when to apply it.”
“Communication matters most in difficult times,” Dr. Russel says. “Employees need clarity and honesty, customers need reassurance that the organization can keep delivering value, and shareholders need a strategic focus that protects long-term value. Leaders must explain new priorities and constraints clearly.”
Dr. Russel points to Airbnb as a case study in communicating under pressure. When travel collapsed during the Covid-19 pandemic, Airbnb laid off nearly 1,900 workers, which came to around a quarter of its total workforce at the time. Airbnb’s CEO, Brian Chesky, explained the reasoning for the layoffs in a memo to employees; he paired the job cuts with severance pay, a year of health coverage, four months of mental health support, and recruiter help for departing staff.
“Even in a painful decision, leaders can act with transparency and care,” Dr. Russel says. “Market downturns test not only a manager’s technical competence but also their character. They reveal who can make difficult decisions thoughtfully, communicate transparently, and keep the trust of the people they lead.”
Market downturns aren’t only about damage control. Often, they present opportunities to take the initiative, too. But instead of focusing on outright growth, managers may need to focus on liquidity and cost control. Hopefully, some of the sound decision-making done during favorable conditions has prepared the business for precisely such a moment.
“A downturn can create opportunities, too,” Dr. Zhao says. “Companies that have maintained financial flexibility may be better positioned to invest while their competitors are pulling back. Long-term planning, combined with flexible and agile decision-making, can help management navigate challenging times while positioning the business for sustainable growth.”
Leading in an Uncertain Future
MBA graduates need to be prepared to lead in an uncertain future, regardless of the market’s temperament. That means taking advantage of the good times while also cultivating the skills and positioning needed to survive and thrive in harder times. Revolutionary tech is to be explored and experimented with — but without getting carried away from the fundamentals of how businesses create value over the long run: with people.
“Focus on developing transferable skills and good judgment, rather than chasing whatever industry or job is most popular at the moment,” Dr. Zhao says. “Markets will go through cycles, but the ability to think critically, adapt, and make sound decisions will always be valuable.”
“In good markets, it is easy to mistake momentum for ability,” Dr. Russel says. “My advice is to invest in what will last when conditions change.”
It’s an exciting time to enter the business world: AI is having enormous impacts and paradigms are shifting. All that change can be unnerving, too. But uncertainty is a constant in business, and risk is just the other side of reward.
“Do not let the ups and downs of the market discourage you,” Dr. Russel says. “A well-trained MBA graduate will always find a place in industry, because the business expertise, financial fluency, judgment, and leadership the degree builds are needed in every kind of economy, and the degree has stood the test of time through many business cycles and waves of technological change. Keep learning, become the person people want on their team, and know that the future remains bright for those who hold an MBA.”